Colored pencil points usually break for three reasons: the pencil was dropped (cracking the lead inside), the sharpener's blade is dull, or the pencil was twisted too hard and too fast. A sharp, simple sharpener used with gentle, steady turns fixes most of it. For children, the best sharpener is one they can use alone, that keeps the shavings inside, and that fits the pencils they actually own.
Below: why points snap, how to sharpen well, and what to look for in a sharpener.
Affiliate disclosure. Some links below go to Amazon, and Meowelo may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon does not sponsor or endorse Meowelo. We list supplies that suit these books, and say what each one is not good for too. Full disclosure.
Why colored pencils keep breaking
| What happens | Likely cause | What helps |
|---|---|---|
| The point snaps while sharpening | Twisting too hard, or a dull blade | Slower turns; a fresh sharpener |
| The point breaks again and again | The lead cracked inside when dropped | Keep pencils in a case; sharpen past the crack |
| The point breaks while coloring | Too sharp and pressed hard | A slightly blunter point for filling |
| The pencil gets stuck | Too thick for the hole | A sharpener with the right hole size |
How to sharpen without snapping
- Hold the sharpener still and turn the pencil, not the other way round.
- Use slow, even turns, without pushing hard into the blade.
- Stop as soon as the point is sharp. Over-sharpening eats pencils.
- For filling big areas, a slightly rounded point breaks less than a needle point.
What to look for in a sharpener
- A shavings container so children can sharpen anywhere.
- A sharp blade: sharpeners do wear out. If it starts chewing, replace it.
- The right holes: many sharpeners fit standard pencils only; thick or triangular pencils may need a bigger hole.
- Simple to use alone, so sharpening becomes part of coloring, not a call for help.
Make sharpening part of the routine
A quick "sharpen three pencils" at the start of coloring time avoids stopping halfway through a sky. Keeping pencils in a case or tin, rather than loose in a drawer, means fewer drops and fewer cracked leads. Our guide to colored pencils for kids covers choosing the pencils themselves, and why kids snap crayons covers the crayon version of the problem.
Manual or electric?
| Manual (hand) sharpener | Electric sharpener | |
|---|---|---|
| Control | The child feels when to stop | Easy to over-sharpen and eat pencils |
| Soft colored pencils | Gentle turns break fewer leads | Can snap soft leads |
| Where it works | Anywhere, including the car | Near a socket, or with batteries |
| Best for | Colored pencils and home coloring | Classrooms sharpening lots of graphite pencils |
For colored pencils at home, a good hand sharpener with a shavings box is usually all a family needs.
Sharpening different pencils
- Soft colored pencils: sharpen less often and more gently; they wear down quickly and break if forced.
- Erasable colored pencils: the leads are softer still (see erasable colored pencils), so slow turns matter.
- Thick or triangular pencils: need a bigger hole. Check before buying, or keep a two-hole sharpener.
- Twist-up pencils: never need sharpening at all, which is why some families choose them.
Signs a sharpener is worn out
- The wood looks chewed or torn instead of cleanly shaved.
- The point keeps snapping off inside the sharpener.
- The pencil gets very hot or squeaks.
- The point comes out off-center, with lead on one side and wood on the other.
Any of these means the blade is dull. A new sharpener costs far less than the pencils a bad one eats.
Teach it once, well
Show your child one slow, careful sharpen, then let them do the next three while you watch. Praise the stopping, not the speed: "You stopped as soon as it was sharp, that saves your pencil." Most children are fully independent after a week, and pencils last noticeably longer.
Where to keep the sharpener
A sharpener that lives in the pencil case gets used; one that lives in a kitchen drawer doesn't. Keep a small sharpener in each place children color: the coloring corner, the travel kit and the school bag. Empty the shavings into the bin at the end of each session, a job most children are happy to do because it's oddly satisfying.
If shavings do escape onto the carpet, a damp cloth picks up the colored dust better than a dry one. And keep sharpeners away from very young siblings: the blade is small but sharp.
Children who sharpen their own pencils also tend to take better care of them: they notice when a point is dull, they put pencils back in the case, and they treat the set as theirs. A small habit like this is one of the easiest ways to make good colored pencils last much longer, and to save on replacing broken ones every few weeks.
Questions parents ask
Why do my child's colored pencils keep breaking?
How do you sharpen colored pencils without breaking them?
What kind of sharpener is best for kids?
Do sharpeners wear out?
The one thing to remember
Gentle turns, a sharp blade and pencils kept in a case. That's most broken points solved.
Conversation
Join the conversation
Tips, questions and stories from other grown-ups. A person reads every comment before it goes live.
No comments yet. What has worked at your house? Your story might be exactly what another parent needs tonight.